With
“Jesus
is Magic
,” the film documenting her full-length stand-up
show, Sarah Silverman gets a forum for subtlety that gets lost in
appearances like Comedy Central’s Pamela Anderson roast.
The film is simply
shot, almost amateurishly so, alternating between close-ups of
Silverman and a wide shot of the theater where you can barely see
her. There are more produced little staged breaks edited into the
stand-up that are funny but a bit jarring at first because it seems
like Silverman had delivered some version of these bits on stage,
but they were replaced with fuller versions with specific costumes
or sets. Viewers will wonder if these worked in the simple
monologue.
Out of a
75-minute film, it’s the last 30 minutes or so of “Jesus Is Magic”
that contain the biggest laugh. Silverman isn’t as consistent yet as
Richard Pryor or other masters of the comedy concert film. But when
she scores, it’s great, because of the way she confounds your
expectations with each joke or story, and thoroughly dismantles
political correctness with offhanded, seemingly naïve remarks.
Her sense of
humor, particularly her sense of absurdity, her writing and her
delivery are all unique. It’s tough to recount examples without
spoiling the surprise of the film, but one example of Silverman’s
sensibility is when she calls something “retarded,” she adds, “and
by retarded, I mean they can do anything,” striking right at the
whole rationale for “correctness.”
Silverman’s
most skillful moments in the latter part of the film come from the
darkest subjects, like the Holocaust and anti-Semites perceptions
about what Jews supposedly control. In fact, as a Jew finding laughs
in these subjects by being completely insensitive about them,
Silverman does something no one else has.
To really enjoy
“Jesus Is Magic,” you must have the same warped point of view as
Silverman does. Even if you do, it does build slowly. But it can be
imagined that some of the bits from this film could find their way
to be remembered and re-told in the same way other stand-up classics
like the work of Pryor or George Carlin still is.